White House Petition – Service Dogs as a Therapy Option for Disabled Service-Connected Combat Veterans suffering from PTSD
We respectfully petition the President and Commander in Chief on behalf of the Disabled Combat Veterans suffering from PTSD related to their service to our country.
Congress and the Executive Branch Acted:
“The Service Dogs for Veterans Act, cosponsored by Senator Johnny Isakson of Georgia, directs the Secretary of Veterans Affairs (VA) to establish a pilot program working in partnership with non-profit service dog agencies to pair service dogs with veterans with physical and mental injuries and disabilities, including Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Senator Franken’s bill was included as an amendment to the National Defense and Authorization Act that passed the Senate on July 23, 2009, and was subsequently signed into law by the President.”
The Veterans Administration has fought this therapy and here is their argument:
This law only provided $2 million in funding, which is completely inadequate. Even at that level the VA resisted the pilot test and buried the program. When Congress acts and the President signs a bill an agency like the VA should simply say “Yes Sir” and do what they are told. This is a case of an agency that has gone rouge causing harm to the treatment of our veterans. Granted they have done this with bureaucratic expertise but it is time for them to step up to their mission and serve the therapy needs of the service connected combat veterans.
Our argument is that dogs are better than drugs.
Service Dogs that are specially trained to assist veterans with PTSD have wide spread support from many experts but the VA does not agree. The VA appears to be a minority of one with a position that this is a poor therapy strategy. They are using all their skills as bureaucrats to wrap this in red tape and stop this therapy while at the same time embracing drugs. There are within the nation organizations that are willing to step up and provide trained dogs but we have to provide support for the expenses they incur. Our recommendation is to set a fair market value in the range of $20,000 – $40,000 based on cost to train the dog plus a reasonable profit margin and then index this to the cost of living. Assuming a reasonable life span of the dog this benefit should be limited to one dog. We would argue that the cost of the dog could be recovered from the lower drug cost by shifting the therapy from drugs to dogs.
Within the Service Dog Training industry there are practices that include the use of prison labor for part of the dog training and an incentive should exist for this. Early studies show that it improves prisoner rehabilitation and lowers the cost of raising the service dog. Organizations that utilize this method or other methods that create other social value should be paid more for their dogs.
To insure the quality of the dogs in the program the VA should have an inspection and certification process for trainers and/or training organizations. Because the VA has been resistant to this therapy, for a reason we do not understand, a provisional certification for the year should be issued to any organization with a mission to train service dogs. The VA will then have one year to inspect the organization and issue or deny a for cause permanent certification. An organization with a provisional certification shall only be allowed to sell 5 dogs per year into the system.
We fully understand the need to maintain control and fair administration and realize that demand for Service Dogs will exceed supply. We propose that the VA maintain a priority list just like the medical profession does for organ donations. The priority should be based on the urgency of need (Doctors recommendation) disability rating of the veteran, valor of service (Medals in DD214), and income (lower income higher priority).
What we request
We request that the President direct the Veterans Administration to provide this option to veterans suffering from PTSD as determined by mental therapy experts with an appeal process that uses Doctors from outside the VA direct control or compensation.
We request that the program be fully funded based on the needs of our Veterans suffering from PTSD related to combat service on behalf of our nation. This should not be a pilot program but a fully funded therapy provided to veterans where therapy is a reasonable course of treatment.
How you can help
For the short term we have a crowdfunding project for a non-profit that trains service dogs and then donates them to our Veterans.
In the long term you can lend your voice to our petition to the White House to direct the VA to do their job and find a way to provide this treatment option to our Disabled Service Connected Veterans suffering from PTSD.